Tuesday, 18 May, 2010 - 16:41
Por Ekain Laka

City Regeneration Policies need to change

During the last 30 years neoliberal inspiration city regeneration policies have shape many of European and US cities. It was back in the 1980's when there was a general consensus on the role of a particular type of projects as the right way for regeneration of many cities of the time. The aims were:

  • Join the run for competitiveness and the New Economy.
  • Engage with global economy and attract international investment and capital flows.
  • Bring new tourist and enhance service economy (culture, financial services...) as an alternative to the loss of jobs in industry and manufacturing.
  • Spread/socialise new neoliberal values: Aestheticism, competitiveness, flexibility...

Once tested in the US and the UK in cities such as Baltimore and Pittsburgh or Newcastle, London and Birmingham, those initiatives were broadly considered successful so they were copied by many others across Europe and even, to some extend, by cities around the rest of the world. Meanwhile, the core strategy in many cities had some of the following ingredients:

  • Big Urban (identikit) Projects, involving huge amount of public investment.
  • Culture (and more recently creative industries) as a tool for local economic recovery.
  • The use of star architects and iconic buildings.
  • Building new spaces for the service economy (technology parks, creative districts...)
  • New high quality streets and public spaces.
  • Refurbished or brand-new commercial districts and malls with increasing presence and market share of global chains and franchises.
  • New governance tools that would use housing market capital gains to finance spatial planning strategies.
  • City marketing strategies as a way of attracting tourists and investors.

After thirty years, those strategies are supposed to have brought plenty of success. Economic growth, jobs, improved image, the rise of a new service economy or better living standards and environment are just some of the positive impacts that, broadly speaking, such initiatives seem to have created. However, critics still continue to raise relevant questions about those processes undertaken: 

  • Has public space been privatised?
  • Have those policies reduce social inequalities in our cities? What kinds of jobs have been created?
  • Are creative and innovative districts what they were supposed to be? Have world-class cultural facilities really succeeded in terms of increasing the cultural production or rising interest on art?
  • Has "regeneration" also meant gentrification, leaving high streets for big corporations, and reducing grassroots social, educational and cultural expenditures?
  • Have those strategies being effective on the fight against growing regional inequalities?

It is not easy to response to those questions and even less if we are thinking on making general statements considering "all cities" in general. However, what seems to be true is that after 30 years of promises, some old other new, challenges continue to be out there:  

  • 'Credit Crunch' has put at risk many City Council budgets and the way of financing strategic spatial plans through a booming housing market.
  • Increasing regional polarisation. The 'brain drain' and the rout of people and even businesses from medium-sized cities to capital cities or abroad.
  • Gentrification and the lack of urban life due too high housing and retail units' costs, the struggle for historic preservation versus modernity in many cities,...
  • The Knowledge Economy. How do we raise grassroots cultural and educational standards in order to meet innovation and creativity challenges?
  • The need of "more and better jobs". The financial crisis has ended up involving the whole economy and has raised unemployment to levels of early 1990's.
  • Growing social inequalities and the gap between the rich and the poor.
  • Ageing.

Some of those are familiar others have raised in the last 10 years due to, for example, globalization or the rise of the knowledge economy. The question here then is quite clear: Are 1980's and 1990's neoliberal policies addressing those issues or do we need to reform them? From my personal point of view, the response to the second question is "Yes, we do". First, because the world we have got in 2010 is very different to the one that we had in 1980's. Second, because those policies have already being launched in almost every city, so we have too many cities offering the same and what is worse, it has not probe useful enough to tackle the biggest challenges of today.

No votes yet

This could interest you

Wednesday, 16 May, 2012 - 18:40

Bring research to the streets, not to cities without people

Center for Innovation Testing and Evaluation (CITE)
It is likely you have heard about this project of building a new city from scratch to test new urban technologies, but no people will be living there. In fact, we first heard about it some months ago ...
Wednesday, 18 April, 2012 - 07:49

Fighting against private car invasion….in 1896

Great Bicycle Demonstration
Some weeks ago I came across a great story in The Urban Country blog. The photograph shows the front cover of the San Francisco Call, headlining a demonstration of thousands of protesters -more than 1 ...
Thursday, 12 April, 2012 - 09:23

History of urbanism in the 20th century in 10 videos

The "video" tag in my Delicious keeps growing and has reached 275 references. I opened this tag to prepare an experiment of facilitating a discussion session in the course Repensar las políticas urban ...
Monday, 9 April, 2012 - 08:05

Local resilience for sustainable societies

Local resilience for sustainable societies
Some months ago I wrote a few lines on Sustainability in austerity. How local governments can deliver during times of crisis, by Philip Monaghan, a book that covers some arguments not to use local bud ...
Monday, 26 March, 2012 - 17:06

Daily scenes in an intelligent city

ateneo naider
@manufernandez  These lines will surely seem naive, but I cannot resist sharing them. In the face of the abundance of sophisticated promises surrounding the idea of the intelligent city, to ...
Thursday, 22 March, 2012 - 18:30

The intelligence of a city is on the streets

The intelligence of a city is on the streets
@manufernandez I recommend listening closely to this speech by Adam Greenfield, founder of Urbanscale and one of the people with the clearest ideas about the role technology can play in urban life. As ...
Wednesday, 21 March, 2012 - 12:59

The time of the temporary city

THE LIDO (Southwark, Londres)
The process of territorial expansion we have experienced in the last two decades particularly in the years before the economic crisis is one of the elements that best contextualizes not only the cause ...
Tuesday, 14 February, 2012 - 15:18

Melbourne laneways. Every space matters

Melbourne
Melbourne is recognized as one of the most livable cities for its quality of life, specially for its vibrant cultural life and the high quality of its public spaces and streets. I was visiting this ci ...
Thursday, 15 December, 2011 - 14:12

10 examples of urban data visualization

binary
@manufernandez The complexity of cities (a diverse and always changing environment) produces a huge amount of data. The growing availability of tools to generate, capture, store, manage and analyze th ...
Monday, 25 April, 2011 - 15:16

Shaping urban infrastructures. Intermediaries and the governance of socio-technical networks

Shaping urban infrastructures. Intermediaries and the governance of socio-techni
This book presents a collection of essays related to urban infrastructures current state of transition, basically represented by the change from centralized to potentially decentralized, and from pass ...

Además en Ateneo Naider

Nature science cities
Factoría Económica
Nature has published a special issue with different articles and interactive data visualization tools covering the relationship between science and cities. Some items are worth reading:
ateneo naider
Factoría Económica
The economic crisis made ourselves reflect on how we could go so far in the excesses in the economy. Almost all economies have not escaped recession, and almost all have questioned with more or less...
Territorio sostenible
The "video" tag in my Delicious keeps growing and has reached 275 references. I opened this tag to prepare an experiment of facilitating a discussion session in the course Repensar las políticas...
Shaping urban infrastructures. Intermediaries and the governance of socio-techni
Construcción social
This book presents a collection of essays related to urban infrastructures current state of transition, basically represented by the change from centralized to potentially decentralized, and from...

Cara a cara con ...

ateneo naider
Bibao 1978. Veterinaria. Tuvo claro nada más terminar la carrera de veterinaria que su futuro estaba sobre el terreno y no en consultas o clínicas de barrio. Después de trabajar en centros de recuperación de especies en Venezuela y Holanda, llegó a Indonesia en 2003 y quedó enganchada por la sensación de haber encontrado finalmente un sitio donde su labor podía marcar la diferencia. Desde entonces, Karmele Llano representa la esencia misma del compromiso personal con la sostenibilidad de nuestro Planeta y de nuestra propia dignidad como seres humanos, mediante la lucha por preservar de una...

Publicaciones de Ateneo Naider

Suscríbete a nuestros boletines
Manage your newsletter subscriptions
Select the newsletter(s) to which you want to subscribe or unsubscribe.